FJORD (2026)
Short version: this is So Much For The Tolerant Left: The Movie.
==
Longer version: to be fair, I don't think Mungiu intended to make So Much For The Tolerant Left: The Movie. I think he intended to make one of those "both sides" puzzlers, one of those movies you could debate at the bar afterward. But that's not really the movie we have.
It's not the movie we have because Mungiu can't really resist stacking the deck against progressive society, perhaps out of a desire to challenge the sensibilities of the liberal theatergoers who will undeniably make up this film's primary audience. (The queer narrative that sneaks in at the margins of the central story could be taken as something of an olive branch, a way for Mungiu to show that it was all in fun.)
I believe Mungiu to be "stacking the deck" here because I have some personal experience with the bureaucracy around child welfare: it is a system I have looked at closely and learned a lot about. I've had close relationships with a couple who were working hard to adopt a child out of the child protective system, and also with a mother who lost custody of her two young children to the same system. And, yes, these systems (like any impersonal state system) sometimes overreach, and yes, separating a family has consequences that can often leave us with ambiguous feelings when considering the work that these services do. But I've also seen the safeguards built into these systems, and I know the exact ways that the system seeks family reunification in all but the most dire of cases. These are the nuances. And when you start shaving off those nuances in order to highlight the small-mindedness and hypocrisy of one "side," you're no longer interested in the real-life ambiguities of this kind of scenario. You're interested in scoring points.
(Is the Norwegian system depicted in the film meaningfully different from the American system I've gotten to know? Maybe... but the people on Letterboxd doing the research also seem to feel like Mungiu is distorting the facts to fit the narrative, and if anything their estimation of the film is lower than mine.)
I must acknowledge that the film is well made, with some phenomenal central performances which have been rightly praised. And if you wanted to, you could also argue that the real point of all this craft on display is not to score points or to create umbrage around a (fictionalized) miscarriage of justice, but rather to remind liberal audiences to run a check on their practices of tolerance, to be sure their progressive bona fides are flexible enough to uplift this family as surely as any other. (This is presumably what the Cannes judges were responding to.) But, you know what? I've lived through the last ten years in America. I've been asked again and again to understand the mindset of the people who can't function in a pluralistic society, to just think about how it looks from their perspective, to try respecting their beliefs and winning them back with a little empathy. I've done this work. I'm tired of doing it. I don't need to be asked to do it again. Certainly I've seen no sign that those people have any interest in extending empathy back to me, or to the people I love. Quite the contrary.