FAT GIRL (2001)
[cw: rape]
Look, I... get it if you don't vibe with Fat Girl. Its overall aura is repellent; its dramatic shape is lopsided; and its very existence is, for lack of a better word, problematic. It sets out to explore various varieties of rape, and its achievements in this regard are memorable, maybe indelibly so, though I hope it is obvious that I intend this as a heavily qualified sort of praise, that one could accomplish this feat without producing a film that is enjoyable or even edifying. Yes, one could argue that a film that honestly grapples with such an ugly topic must itself become ugly in the process — but the use of untrained underage actors in such a scenario surely negates at least some of the ethical good arguably being achieved here. In fact, I think one could argue that it constitutes its own form of violation — an unintended example of the cultural forces it intends to critique (it is in fact the rare film about which I might consider there to be a valid moral case for its censorship).
The great Jonathan Rosenbaum, writing about a different Breillat film (Romance), writes "France is in many respects a prefeminist country, even though it has produced feminist thinkers ranging from Simone de Beauvoir to Christine Delphy and perhaps more talented women filmmakers than anywhere else in the world. This results in a kind of women’s cinema that might be considered backward by the usual American standards." I don't have enough European Women's Studies knowledge to really know how accurate his observation is, but it does have a kind of truthiness, and it does help to put the finger on why Fat Girl feels so strange: it feels like the work of someone who reached a critique of rape culture but who got to it without ever passing through the circuit of (bourgeois middle class?) feminist thinking that I was more or less schooled in. The end result feels analytical in an alien but not unintelligent way, driven by an anger that runs ice cold rather than hot. It feels weirdly repulsive at every moment, like touching a reptile, and, like I said, surely not everyone is going to vibe with it. But I think it's a fascinating (if not pleasant) experience to spend time considering this material from a perspective that doesn't seek to flatter my own. Whether it's worth the feeling of moral uncleanliness one is left with is an open question.
[Rating withheld.]